Joe from Queens

Joe from Queens

Volume 39- Bills, Takes, And Dad Mistakes

The Bills are 8-1 under Joe Brady. But are they actually better than the teams we watched under Sean McDermott? Diana Russini PR blunder. The Sabres issues. The Democrats need new leadership

Joe from Queens's avatar
Joe from Queens
Nov 17, 2026
∙ Paid

Different and Better?

Our main story today is “Different and Better?”

That’s the question I keep coming back to when watching the Buffalo Bills. Are they different from the teams we’ve watched over the years under Sean McDermott? And, more importantly, are they actually better? We all know what the expectations are when it comes to the Buffalo Bills. I hate using the phrase “Super Bowl or bust,” but let’s face it, we’re pretty damn close to that territory. Getting to the playoffs isn’t enough anymore. Winning the division isn’t enough. Hell, even winning a playoff game isn’t enough.

The Bills are 8-1. That’s great. Nobody should be complaining about an 8-1 football team. But as I sit here writing this, I keep coming back to the same conclusion.

They feel like the same Bills teams we’ve watched for years.

When I logged onto Twitter on Monday morning, it felt like everybody was arguing about whether these Bills are actually different from the teams we’ve watched over the years. And there was definitely a little sense of entitlement. People shitting on anybody who thinks this team is the same, and others basically doing the exact opposite to anyone who thinks things have changed.

And I’m sitting there thinking, why does everything have to be so black and white? Why can’t somebody question whether an 8-1 team is actually better without being treated like an idiot? And why can’t somebody believe this team is different without getting shit on for being optimistic?

That whole back-and-forth is what made me want to go down this rabbit hole. Instead of just arguing about feelings, vibes and what we think we’re seeing every Sunday, why not actually look at the numbers? Compare the previous seasons, look at the opponents, and see if there’s something that really separates this team from the others.

Because maybe I’m wrong. Maybe they are different. But I’d rather find out for myself than have somebody on Twitter tell me what I’m supposed to think.

What’s funny is that I can go back through almost every season of the Josh Allen era and remember how we convinced ourselves that particular team was different.

Remember 2021? The Bills curb-stomped the Chiefs 38-20 after losing to them twice the previous season. They finished the regular season with four straight wins, then absolutely demolished the Patriots in the Wild Card round for their fifth consecutive victory. All that momentum, all that confidence, and everyone thinking this was finally our year. Then came 13 fucking seconds. Just another reminder that what you do in the regular season doesn’t mean shit when January rolls around.

In 2022, the Bills brought in Von Miller. He was supposed to be the missing piece. Then came all the adversity, from injuries and snowstorms to the unimaginable situation involving Damar Hamlin. It felt like the team was going through something that would bring everyone together. They were battle-tested. They beat KC in the regular season for a signature win. They had destiny on their side.

Except they didn’t.

Then came 2023. Ken Dorsey gets fired, Joe Brady takes over, and suddenly everybody is talking about balance. James Cook is getting the football. The running game becomes a bigger part of the offense. Khalil Shakir is emerging. Josh Allen doesn’t have to do everything himself.

Remember how refreshing that felt? We convinced ourselves that the Bills finally figured out a different way to win. They beat KC in the regular season for another signature win.

And nothing changed.

In 2024, Allen wins MVP. Stefon Diggs is gone, and suddenly the narrative becomes that Allen is free. He doesn’t have to force-feed one receiver. Everybody eats. The defense is getting turnovers. The vibes are incredible. Sean McDermott is making snow angels. [CTRL Copy and Paste] They beat KC in the regular season for a signature win.

This was finally the year, right?

Wrong.

And last year, the argument was that the AFC wasn’t quite as intimidating. The Chiefs weren’t the same obstacle. The path was supposed to be there.

Another season without a Super Bowl.

Now here we are in 2026 with a new head coach, and I’m hearing the same things again. This team is different. This team is better. Joe Brady has changed the culture.

Okay. But where’s the proof?

Let’s look at the numbers

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Joe from Queens.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Joe · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.