The opening
I’m going to be honest. There’s absolutely nothing I’m going to learn about the Buffalo Bills on Sunday that I don’t already know, or at least think I know, after watching them the last three weeks.
The Bills could come out and beat the Dolphins 40-0. They could struggle for three quarters before eventually winning by 10 points. Hell, they could barely squeak by this terrible Miami team, and I’m still going to feel pretty much the same way about Buffalo as I did coming into the game.
And that’s because the last three weeks haven’t exactly been the greatest measuring stick for this team. They’ve played inferior competition, particularly at quarterback, and while I’ve enjoyed watching the defense improve and the offense put together some decent performances, I’m not ready to declare that all their problems have suddenly disappeared.
So what am I looking for on Sunday?
No injuries. That’s it.
Seriously. That’s my entire wish list. Go out there, beat the living hell out of Miami in the first half, build a three- or four-touchdown lead, and then get Josh Allen, James Cook and anyone else important the hell off the field.
I’ve already watched enough players get hurt in games where they probably shouldn’t have been playing anymore. I don’t need to see Josh Allen scrambling for a first down in the fourth quarter of a game Buffalo is winning by 24 points. I don’t need to see James Cook carrying the ball 25 times just because the Bills want to run up the score.
Get the win, stay healthy and move on. That’s all I care about.
Now, with that out of the way, let’s look at the Dolphins.
Tale of the teams
The Bills are 8-1, while Miami is sitting at 1-8. Buffalo is averaging 31.9 points per game, compared with just 16.4 for the Dolphins. And when it comes to total offense, the Bills are averaging 386.7 yards per game to Miami’s 283.4.
The biggest thing that jumps out at me is the difference in yards per play. Buffalo is at 6.13, while Miami is at an even 5.00. That’s a pretty significant gap when you stretch it out over an entire game.
But here’s one stat that surprised me. Miami is converting 40.2% of its third downs, which isn’t that far off Buffalo’s 41.0%. So while the Dolphins have been lousy offensively, they’re at least capable of putting together a drive here and there.
Whether they can actually finish those drives is another story.
Josh Allen has already beaten two first-time NFL head coaches in 2026, and Sunday’s matchup with Miami’s Jeff Hafley would be his third opportunity this season.
Against those two coaches, Allen is 2–0, with 544 passing yards, four passing touchdowns, one interception, 31 rushing yards and one rushing touchdown. CBS Sports +
Stathead of the game: Josh Allen against Rookie Head Coaches
In 25 games where he played meaningful snaps against first-time, non-interim head coaches, Allen is 21–4, throwing for 6,167 yards and 39 touchdowns while adding another 12 touchdowns on the ground.
Of course, one of those four losses came against Mike McDaniel’s Dolphins in 2022, when Allen threw for 400 yards and Buffalo somehow lost 21–19.
But Allen has already beaten two rookie head coaches this season, Klint Kubiak and Jesse Minter. Now he gets Jeff Hafley, who is in his first season running the Dolphins.
Five things about the Dolphins
1. It’s another backup quarterback
I almost feel like I’m writing the same thing every week at this point. The Bills are going up against another backup quarterback, this time Kyle McCord, who will be making his second NFL start.
McCord completed 17 of 32 passes for 209 yards last week against Indianapolis. No touchdown passes, no interceptions, and a lost fumble that the Colts returned for a touchdown.
I don’t know how many more backup quarterbacks Buffalo can possibly face this season, but I’m certainly not going to complain about it. Just don’t tell me that shutting down another inexperienced quarterback automatically means this defense has arrived.
2. Ollie Gordon has become their running game
Ollie Gordon II has 539 rushing yards on 127 carries, averaging 4.2 yards per attempt with four touchdowns.
With De’Von Achane having played in only three games, Gordon has become the guy Miami relies on to move the ball on the ground.
I don’t think Gordon is a bad player by any means, but if Buffalo can shut down Miami’s rushing attack and force McCord into obvious passing situations, I have a hard time seeing how the Dolphins consistently move the football.
3. Who the hell is Caleb Douglas?
I’m sure plenty of people who don’t follow Miami closely probably haven’t heard much about Caleb Douglas, but the rookie is having an interesting season.
Douglas has 22 receptions for 367 yards and two touchdowns, averaging 16.7 yards per catch. He’s also averaging more than 61 receiving yards per game in his six appearances.
Malik Washington leads the team with 36 receptions for 400 yards.
Obviously, this isn’t exactly Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle at their peak, but Douglas is somebody worth paying attention to. He’s shown he can make some plays downfield, even in an offense that has struggled to do much of anything.
4. Chop Robinson might be their best defensive player
Miami has just 13 sacks as a team through nine games, which is the fewest in the NFL. That’s pretty remarkable when you consider that Chop Robinson has five of them himself.
Robinson has been especially productive recently. He had seven quarterback pressures against Indianapolis last week, along with a sack and a forced fumble.
He’s the one guy on that defensive front I’d be paying particular attention to. The Dolphins haven’t been able to consistently get after opposing quarterbacks, but Robinson can still wreck a play.
5. Opposing quarterbacks are having a field day
If there’s one thing that should make Bills fans feel pretty good about this matchup, it’s Miami’s pass defense.
Opposing quarterbacks have completed 73.7% of their passes against the Dolphins, throwing 17 touchdowns against seven interceptions. Miami is allowing a 107.5 opposing quarterback rating.
Think about that for a second.
Almost three out of every four passes against this defense have been completed. And now they’re going up against Josh Allen.
I don’t need Allen to throw for 400 yards or five touchdowns on Sunday. But if he wants to, the opportunities should certainly be there.
Four advanced stats
I wanted to look at four numbers that give us a little better picture of how these two offenses have performed beyond the basic passing yards and points per game.
Adjusted net yards per attempt: Buffalo is averaging 7.5 ANY/A, while Miami is at 5.2. This takes into account sacks, touchdowns and interceptions, and it’s another illustration of just how much more efficient Buffalo’s passing game has been.
On-target percentage: Buffalo is at 75.6%, compared with Miami’s 68.5%. That’s a pretty big difference, and it tells you that Miami’s struggles aren’t just about poor pass protection. Its quarterbacks haven’t been nearly as accurate, either.
Yards after the catch: The Bills are averaging 6.0 yards after the catch per completion, compared with 4.4 for Miami. The difference is that Buffalo has been able to turn those shorter throws into bigger gains. Miami hasn’t had nearly the same success.
Fourth-down conversions: Buffalo has converted 10 of 12 fourth-down attempts, while Miami is 6-for-14. Different situations obviously dictate when teams go for it, but that’s still a pretty dramatic difference in execution.
In the trenches: Buffalo’s offensive line vs. Miami’s offensive line
This is something I’ve wanted to look at because I think Buffalo’s offensive line has been pretty good overall, even with the injuries and occasional problems.
Through nine games, Buffalo has allowed 18 sacks for 117 yards lost. Miami has given up 27 sacks for 152 yards. That’s nine more sacks in the same number of games.
The pressure numbers are even more interesting. Buffalo’s quarterbacks have been pressured on 19.7% of their dropbacks, while Miami is at 26.1%.
And here’s the part that jumps out at me. Buffalo has faced 97 blitzes, while Miami has faced only 86. Despite seeing more blitzes, the Bills have allowed 19 fewer total pressures.
So the Dolphins aren’t just getting overwhelmed because everybody is blitzing them. They’re having trouble protecting the quarterback, period.
Now, one thing I want to make clear is that sacks and pressures aren’t exclusively offensive line statistics. Quarterbacks holding onto the ball, running backs missing blocks and receivers not getting open all play a part. Still, when you see a difference this significant, it’s worth talking about.
Where are these teams running the football?
This is where things get interesting.
The Bills are averaging 7.1 yards per carry when they run off right tackle. That’s on 28 attempts, so it’s not some number based on two or three runs.
Miami, meanwhile, is averaging only 3.3 yards per carry running in that same direction.
Buffalo is also averaging 4.4 yards per attempt running through the middle and guard areas, compared with 3.6 for Miami. Both teams run through the middle more than anywhere else, but Buffalo is doing a much better job of getting production.
Miami has actually been pretty successful running off left tackle, averaging 5.4 yards per carry on 17 attempts.
What I find interesting is how different the two teams are in the middle of the offensive line. Buffalo has been more effective running between the tackles, while Miami has struggled to consistently get those four- and five-yard gains.
And again, that brings us back to McCord. If Miami is constantly facing third-and-8 because it can’t run the football, that’s going to be a problem.
James Cook vs. Ollie Gordon II
Cook has 971 rushing yards and nine touchdowns on 187 carries, averaging 5.2 yards per attempt. Gordon has 539 yards and four touchdowns on 127 carries, averaging 4.2 yards per attempt.
Look, this isn’t particularly close.
Cook has been one of the best running backs in football this season, and Buffalo’s offense has benefited tremendously from what he’s been able to do.
The one thing I don’t want is for Cook to have to carry the football 25 times on Sunday. If the Bills are up big, give the guy a break.
Dalton Kincaid vs. Greg Dulcich
Kincaid has 32 receptions for 487 yards and two touchdowns. Dulcich has 24 receptions for 270 yards and no touchdowns.
What I find most impressive about Kincaid is his 15.2 yards per reception. That’s a terrific number for a tight end, especially considering that Buffalo uses him in a variety of ways.
Dulcich has been a decent option for Miami, but Kincaid has been considerably more explosive.
Greg Rousseau vs. Chop Robinson
Rousseau has eight sacks this season, while Robinson has five.
I’ve really liked what Rousseau has done, especially during this recent stretch where the Bills defense has improved. Robinson, meanwhile, is one of the few Dolphins defenders who has consistently generated pressure.
It’ll be interesting to see whether Buffalo can keep Robinson from making the kind of impact plays he’s been making lately.
Tale of the Tape
Four random Bills-Dolphins games I remember
One of my favorite things about doing these previews is going back through games that have stuck with me over the years. Sometimes it’s a great play. Sometimes it’s a terrible loss. And sometimes it’s something completely unrelated to the game itself.
Here are four Bills-Dolphins games that I still remember for different reasons.
September 10, 1989: Bills 27, Dolphins 24
This is honestly one of the first Bills games I can ever remember watching.
The Bills were trailing Miami 24-13 late in the fourth quarter when Jim Kelly brought them all the way back. He threw a touchdown pass to Flip Johnson, and then, on the final play, Kelly scored on a two-yard quarterback run to win the game.



But here’s what I remember more than anything else.
My sister absolutely lost her mind.
She was jumping on the couch, screaming and going crazy when Kelly scored. And I remember sitting there watching her, thinking to myself, I have absolutely no idea what the hell is happening right now, but apparently this is pretty awesome, so I guess I’m excited too.
I was only nine years old, and that was probably one of the first moments I can remember truly experiencing what it was like to be a Bills fan.
It’s funny how you remember things like that. I couldn’t tell you every play from that game, but I can still picture my sister going nuts on the couch.
December 1, 2002: Bills 38, Dolphins 21
This was the famous Drew Bledsoe snow game, and it’s still one of my favorite Bills-Dolphins games of all time.
I had just moved to New York earlier that year, and I remember going over to my cousin’s house to watch the game because I was flying back later that night. The weather was absolutely ridiculous. Snow coming down, the Dolphins in town, and Drew Bledsoe was throwing the football all over the place.
Bledsoe finished with 306 passing yards and three touchdown passes, including that beautiful 73-yard touchdown to Peerless Price, who then was hugged by Jim Kelly.


Buffalo won 38-21, and I remember thinking that this was the kind of game we had all been hoping for when the Bills traded for Bledsoe.
Looking back, it honestly felt like the last truly great Drew Bledsoe game with the Bills. Maybe he had some good performances afterward, but this was the one that really stands out to me.
The snow, the crowd, the rivalry and those deep passes to Price. It was just an awesome football game.
And for a brief moment, you really thought this Bledsoe-led Bills team might actually turn into something.
December 30, 2018: Bills 42, Dolphins 17
I remember watching this game and thinking, holy crap, maybe the Bills actually have something with Josh Allen. It was the last game of his rookie season, and Buffalo absolutely curb-stomped Miami.
Allen accounted for five touchdowns, throwing three and rushing for two. He also had that 30-yard touchdown run that made you realize just how ridiculous his athletic ability was.
Now, let’s not rewrite history here. Allen was pretty bad during his rookie season. There were some really ugly performances, and plenty of people [ raises hand] wondered whether the Bills had made a mistake drafting him.
But this game was different.
It was the best performance he had put together to that point, and it gave you a reason to believe that maybe, just maybe, this kid was going to be pretty damn good. This was also Kyle Williams last game as a Bill and he caught a pass for the first time in his career.



And as an added bonus, the Dolphins fired Adam Gase after the season.
Of course, the Jets somehow thought hiring that idiot was a great idea. But that’s another story.
October 13, 1996: Dolphins 21, Bills 7
Now let’s talk about one that still pisses me off.
The Dolphins came into Buffalo without Dan Marino. Instead, they had Craig Erickson starting at quarterback.
Craig freaking Erickson.
I remember looking at that matchup and thinking the Bills were going to boat-race these idiots right out of town.
Instead, Jim Kelly was absolutely awful.
Kelly threw three interceptions, was sacked seven times and couldn’t get anything going offensively. Terrell Buckley returned one of those interceptions 91 yards for a touchdown, and Miami won 21-7.
I remember Kelly being brutally critical of himself afterward, and I couldn’t really disagree with him.



But what sticks with me more than anything is that this was one of the first games where I genuinely started thinking Jim Kelly might be finished.
And I hated thinking that.
Kelly was the quarterback I grew up watching. He was the guy who took the Bills to four straight Super Bowls. And while he had certainly struggled before, something about this game felt different and his stats that season were awful.
I remember thinking that if Kelly couldn’t beat a Miami team starting Craig Erickson, what exactly did that say about where he was in his career?
It was one of those moments where I started realizing that the Bills teams I grew up loving weren’t going to be around forever.
Final thoughts
I don’t really have a prediction for this game beyond the obvious fact that Buffalo should win.
Just give me a win with no injuries.
That’s it.
Please, for the love of God, get through Sunday healthy.












