Bills Press conference from hell or heaven??

My thoughts on the Terry Pegula and Brandon Beane press conference

1. There’s so much to break down, but one quote I wanted to focus on was when Terry Pegula said, “I don’t like power-play guys.” One thought I had was that maybe, in his mind, he felt Sean McDermott was trying to make a power play.

Let’s go over a few things. I’ve heard from the grapevine—two different sources—that at the owners’ meetings in March 2025, Sean McDermott went off the record and told a few media members that he was not happy with Brandon Beane’s draft picks or free-agent selections. Specifically, he wasn’t a fan of the Joey Bosa signing. He also wasn’t a fan of the Dalton Kincaid and Keon Coleman picks.

Then you factor in all the little shots he took across the bow toward Beane—whether it was the Slay/Ingram fiasco, being visibly upset that Joey Bosa was missing OTAs because of a calf injury, or saying he loved the roster but not that it was a championship roster, as Brandon Beane had said it was. Publicly, McDermott was sending out messages that this was not a good-enough roster.

⸻

2. The press conference also reinforced, in my opinion, that Terry Pegula is very, very involved in football operations. He talked about how Brandon Beane will tell him to F off numerous times when it comes to players. That’s fine and dandy, but were there other moments that suggested Beane doesn’t say that when Terry really wants a player.

If I were to speculate and put two and two together, maybe Pegula loved Joey Bosa and said, “Man, we should sign that guy,” and Beane responded with, “Yeah, he’s pretty good.” The idea that Terry just shows up, says hi, and then goes golfing is idiotic. He is involved, and that’s not something I’m a fan of.

⸻

3. If it were up to me, and Beane and McDermott were no longer able to work together, I would have fired both of them and started from scratch. It’s too hard for me to figure out who is truly at fault.

⸻

4. It will be very interesting to see how this new power structure gets covered by the local media. In my opinion, the local media assumed there were problems between Beane and McDermott, and that Beane was going to lose out. They definitely fed into McDermott’s jabs and echoed how bad the roster supposedly was.

Now that we know Beane “won,” or that Pegula went with him, I can see people jumping in to defend Beane and smear McDermott. If you think Terry telling everyone that the coaching staff wanted Keon Coleman was a one-off, I think you’re going to be in for a surprise. It wouldn’t shock me if we start hearing rumblings that McDermott or the rest of the coaching staff wanted certain players who turned into draft or free-agent busts.

It’s the same stuff we heard during the drought—like when Dick Jauron was blamed for wanting Aaron Maybin.

⸻

5. While I think Terry Pegula is an idiot, I don’t think his press conference was that bad. I view it in a few different ways.

What makes someone a bad public speaker? To me, it’s someone who can’t get their words out, has senior moments, misremembers things, or talks about topics completely unrelated to the question. I don’t think Terry had those issues. What he did have was verbal diarrhea—he told people things the public didn’t previously know.

I’ll give him some rope here: it’s hard to explain why Beane is staying while McDermott is leaving when you’re using playoff failures as justification. It’s hard to prop one guy up while dumping on the other when they’ve both been here for the exact same amount of time. Furthermore I think there’s a local surprise reaction when hearing an owner talk about how forthcoming they are because he never talks. If you listen to other NFL owners, they are all micro managers. They can’t help themselves. They want to be like Jerry Jones and Al Davis. Look at the Browns owner, he definitely wanted Watson. How about the Giants owner when it came to Barkley? How about the press conference at the Baltimore Ravens? Owner said where he indicated that even if Jim Harbaugh won against Pittsburgh, he was going to fire him. The point I’m trying to make is the days of the owner just sitting in his owner box and using the Team as a way to impress other Billioanires is a thing of the past. They are involved and I think the reason why Terry doesn’t talk is he will say too much about his involvement and that won’t help with public trust.

⸻

6. I’m a conspiracy theorist when it comes to the inner workings of an NFL franchise, but part of me wonders how much Bills president Pete Guelli had to do with this. He ended up getting promoted, which I don’t really get.

The main thing is that he comes from the NBA. How often do NBA teams fire accomplished coaches? It happens constantly. Maybe he was someone who told Terry change has to happen

⸻

7. What perplexes a lot of Bills fans is: why now? I’ve seen revisionist history saying theyshould’ve done this after 13 seconds or after the Bengals game. To me, if they were going to do this, it should’ve been in 2023—when they had the Chiefs at home in the divisional round and lost.

I actually think McDermott did one of his best coaching jobs this season, considering all the injuries and how bad the wide receiver room was. What ultimately happened, in my opinion, is that the GM, the coach, and the owner simply could not get on the same page anymore.

If you haven’t heard im on a Sunday podcasts with Talking Buffalo Podcast

and I’ll be off until probably February 1st. So please subscribe to his page and also tell him he sucks

-Joe from Queens or Joe at Buffalo wins-